Oversight Record · 2 of 5 · Republican · Florida FL-03 · Energy & Commerce
Rep. Kat Cammack (R-FL)
U.S. House · Energy & Commerce · The "Not One Hand" Moment · January 22, 2026
What She Did That No One Else Did
At the January 22, 2026 House hearing with the CEOs of the five largest health insurers, Cammack didn't ask for a promise or a statistic. She asked for a show of hands. Raise your hand, she said, if an executive at your company takes a financial penalty when a patient is harmed by an insurer-caused delay or wrongful denial. Not one hand went up. She asked again — does an overturned denial or a lost appeal ever dent executive compensation? Again, not one hand. In two questions and about thirty seconds, she made the accountability gap visible to anyone watching: the people who decide whether care is covered face no personal cost when that decision is wrong.
The Moment · Watch It
Clip from Rep. Cammack's official account — opens on Instagram (226K+ likes, 10K+ shares). For the full hearing footage and the citable record, see the House Energy & Commerce hearing page and C-SPAN link in Sources below.
On the Record · January 22, 2026
"I asked health insurance CEOs to raise their hands if they're penalized when patients are harmed by delays or wrongful denials. Not. One. Hand. Patients pay the price. Executives protect the profits. That's the problem."
— Rep. Kat Cammack (R-FL), summarizing her Energy & Commerce exchange
From the hearing floor: "…when denials and delays and appeals — which happen every single day — occur, the patient and their families are the ones that get hurt, not your bottom line."
— Rep. Cammack, to the assembled insurer CEOs
The Same Question From the Other Aisle
On the same day, in the same building, those five CEOs testified twice — before Energy & Commerce in the morning, where Rep. Kat Cammack (R-FL) asked whether any executive is ever penalized when a patient is harmed — and before Ways & Means in the afternoon, where Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) put the CVS CEO on the record about vertical integration and called for a "Glass-Steagall for Health Care."
A Republican and a Democrat — two people who, on nearly everything else, treat one another as the enemy — walked into the same fight through opposite doors and asked the same question. The CEOs handed both of them the same silence. Tribalism runs on "not self." This entry is the record of where the "other side" turns out to be the same side. A wrongful denial does not check which aisle you sit on before it takes a leg. Neither should the answer.
The Question Named a Gap · A Bill Filled It
Cammack asked whether executives face any penalty for the harm that denials and delays cause. The answer, by their own hands, was no. About a month later, Sen. Elizabeth Warren's S.3829 proposed exactly that penalty — creating executive accountability and opening insurer records to investigators. A Republican named the hole on camera; a Democrat drafted the patch a month later. The congressional record identified the gap before the legislation moved to close it.
Why This Is Here — and What It Is Not
This is not an endorsement of Rep. Cammack's politics — it's about one true question she asked, on camera, that no one with the power to answer would.
Congressional Voices is a record, not a roster. A good question counts here whether it comes from the left or the right — because the accountability of insurers to the patients they harm was never a left-or-right question. It is a Civil Rights question: whether Americans still have fair access to medically necessary care. It is being asked, and dodged, on both sides of the aisle.
Tell Them AbilityForge Sent You
This member put the executive-accountability gap on the record, on camera, in front of the CEOs themselves. Contact her office to express appreciation and urge her to keep pressing — legislation that penalizes executives for patient harm needs champions on the right as much as the left. Every constituent call is part of the record.
Sources
- House Energy & Commerce, Subcommittee on Health — Hearing with Health Insurance Company CEOs, January 22, 2026
- C-SPAN — Health Care Executives Testify on Insurance Affordability (full hearing footage)
- American College of Gastroenterology — "Health Insurance CEOs Grilled in Congress: 5 Must-See Moments," Jan 29, 2026 (transcribes the Cammack exchange)
- Rep. Kat Cammack, official Instagram — the "Not One Hand" clip
- CEOs testifying: Stephen Hemsley (UnitedHealth Group), David Joyner (CVS Health), Gail Boudreaux (Elevance Health), David Cordani (The Cigna Group), Paul Markovich (Ascendiun) — per the committee record above.
Other Members in This Series