Case XIV · Survived
Matt Conway
Hartford, Connecticut · Torn Bicep, Delayed Surgery · Prior AuthorizationPrior AuthorizationA requirement that a provider obtain the insurer's approval before a test, procedure, or drug is covered. The approval can be delayed or refused — holding up care the treating doctor has already ordered, sometimes urgently.
A Month, Then Fifteen Minutes, Then Thirty-Seven Hours
Matt Conway tore his bicep delivering a table. Getting it fixed meant first surviving what he called "a month of navigating structural insurance blockades." When he finally reached the orthopedic surgeon, it took the surgeon about fifteen minutes to examine him and order an MRI marked "STAT" — urgent — so they could proceed to surgery.
He could not schedule the MRI that day. His insurer required prior authorization first. So instead of getting the scan his surgeon had just ordered as urgent, Conway started dialing.
It took 37 hours of relentless phone calls to get the insurance company to approve his surgeon's "STAT" order. By the time the approval came and the MRI was done, the delay had pushed the scan into the late hours of a Friday — which meant the results could not be read until days later.
"A 37-hour insurance delay easily turns into a 4-day medical delay. When you are facing a closing window for surgery, every single hour counts."
"Doctors should be allowed to practice medicine, and patients shouldn't have to fight a bureaucracy just to follow their surgeon's urgent orders."
— Matt Conway, in a post chronicling the ordeal, to the Hartford Courant, June 2026
The Window Closed While He Waited
A torn bicep is a race against the tendon. While Conway waited out the authorization, his bicep retracted — the muscle pulling back from where it should be reattached — making the eventual surgery more complicated and more risky than it would have been had the scan happened the day his surgeon ordered it.
Nothing was technically denied. The MRI was approved. The surgery happened. But the procedure he finally received was not the same procedure his surgeon could have performed on day one, because the body does not hold still for paperwork.
What This Case Proves About the Mechanism
Most denial cases turn on a "no." Matt Conway's turns on a "not yet." There was never a final denial — the scan and the surgery were both covered. The harm was manufactured entirely out of delay: a 37-hour administrative bottleneck that the calendar converted into a four-day medical one, inside a window where the tissue was actively changing.
It is the cleanest illustration that a delay is a denial of timely care. An approval that arrives after the window has moved is not the same as the care the doctor ordered — it is a more complicated, riskier version of it, with the difference absorbed by the patient's body. The same mechanism a past AMA president described in the Courant's coverage: a cancer patient whose PET scan took a month to approve, and a lymph node that "wasn't there a month before."
Matt Conway is one of the more than 1 in 4.
The same article cites the AMA's 2025 survey: more than 1 in 4 physicians report that prior authorization caused a serious adverse event for a patient in their care. Conway is the lived shape of that statistic — the count insurers' own shareholders have demanded and never received.
Connecticut — For the Record
According to the Connecticut Insurance Department's Report Card, the state's insurers saved $187 million by requiring prior authorizations in 2024. In Connecticut, the share of benefits requiring prior authorization runs from 4% (Anthem) and 13% (Cigna) to 32% (ConnectiCare) and 38% (UnitedHealthcare). The Courant put data questions to Anthem, Cigna, ConnectiCare and UnitedHealthcare; none answered the questions about how many claims they denied or how many prior authorizations they issued.
Source figures as reported by the Hartford Courant, June 22, 2026, citing the Connecticut Insurance Department's 2025 Consumer Report Card (2024 data). Conway's specific insurer was not named in the reporting; this account reflects his description of events.
He didn't just survive it. He organized.
A former health care strategist who now runs The RiseUP Group Inc. in Hartford, Conway founded the CT Patient & Provider Protection Coalition — patients, healthcare workers, and community organizations "fighting to make health insurance actually work" — to challenge the delay-and-deny tactics he says are harming patients and burning out physicians. As he put it: "It impacts every single person whether you are poor, middle class or have great insurance from your employer."
Has this happened to you?
Every documented case adds to the evidentiary record. Your story matters.